404 issue

[golden]

I password protected a folder. It comes up 404. The issue is not with my hosts server. No 404 errors show in log.
We tested using my other (non WP) domain on my account, works fine.

I thought the 404 was caused by a caching plugin. Cleared cache, deactivated & deleted it. Deactivated all other plugins one by one and the 404 remains.

I don't remember how I set up the 404. The password protected folder also has robots.txt to prevent indexing and archiving.

I am not sure why I am getting the 404 instead of the password prompt.

http://www.pittsburghweddingphotographer.com/golden/


current plugins:
Akismet

BackupBuddy deactivated

Blog Protector

Broken Link Checker deactivated

CommentLuv Premium

Comment Reply Notification

FancyBox for WordPress

Genesis Simple Edits

Genesis Simple Hooks

Google Analytics for WordPress

Gravity Forms

Gravity Forms ShootQ Add-On

Limit Login Attempts

NextGEN Gallery

SEO Friendly Images

Twitter Facebook Social Share

WordPress SEO

WP Smush.it deactivated