Is a better search possible

Community Forums Forums Forum Bugs and Suggestions Is a better search possible

Tagged: 

This topic contains 6 replies, has 4 voices, and was last updated by  And_or 1 year, 5 months ago.

Viewing 7 posts - 1 through 7 (of 7 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #330

    And_or
    Participant
    Post count: 42

    (re post as per request by Brian)

    For me the success of the forum will depend a lot on the search function… Just tested by grabbing a few random words and found that I only get results when it is a word from the title of the post… That is not very promising

    Grtz.  Henk


    Simplicity is not Simple Webtaurus

    #399

    nickthegeek
    Keymaster
    Post count: 751

    This is something Brian and I talked about in the days before the new forums. We did some quick code to get basic search functionality in place and will be working on this when we can steal the big brains for a much better search system. We also need to wait for several threads/replies because having 2 threads didn’t really help us with testing.

    That said, what kinds of search features are most important to you in this type of setting? Have you ever seen a really great search tool? What was is that made it great?

    #414

    And_or
    Participant
    Post count: 42

    I deliver most websites with the plugin “Search Everything” enabled (with search term highlighting in the results) Which would be fine for the size that the new Forum is now, but I don’t know if it works as well on a large site, what the forum should again become…

    Also the Relevanssi Plugin seems to do a good job. Just used it on 1 website, so I would not be able to give you a well funded opinion.  Their premium features look good also.

    A really nice search would open a window and have a 2 boxes – one for the terms to include and another one  for the terms to exclude and a simple selection of which part of the website to search.

    Results should display much like on the ‘old’  forum similar to a category display, showing 400 – 500 characters of each relevant post… Even better would be if it just shows the part of the post(s) where the search terms occur.


    Simplicity is not Simple Webtaurus

    #847

    tbray09
    Participant

    I second this. The new forum seems like a hack of wordpress rather than a support system. At the moment I can’t search the old forums and there is not enough content over here to get questions answered. Studiopress, you once had a vibrant support community that was easy for users and difficult for staff. What we have here looks like a vendor-centric solution to an internal problem that was sold as “We are very excited”. Whenever I hear those words, I think “This is all about the vendor”.

    #848

    Brian Gardner
    Keymaster
    Post count: 17

    This forum is not meant for support – rather discussion about WordPress, design and the likes.

    Official support is taken care of in our new My.StudioPress member portal, and is most certainly not a hack. We spent months building something with our users in mind. Not only can you get one-on-one support for your support and technical questions, you’re also able to immediately receive a 25% discount on anything from our site when you’re logged in.


    #849

    Brian Gardner
    Keymaster
    Post count: 17

    I will see what I can do to make the search function here better, as I completely agree that it is important for any use.


    #856

    And_or
    Participant
    Post count: 42

    Unfortunately the ticket support system makes the whole process “closed”  Where as the forum is transparent… I can see just how fast you guys are in giving support… without ever asking a question.

    The search on the old forum solved the majority of my questions without having to bother the mods. And often in the meantime gave me ideas on how to improve things that I was doing by just reading the questions and answers.

    This forum is not meant for support – rather discussion about WordPress, design and the likes.”  I have seen you and Nick write that… but I really do not think users are interpreting it that way. And if they do it will be a great loss.
    Genesis changes the way we use WordPress quite a lot and its very useful to be able to be part of a specialized forum (also for the sense of community which we and StudioPress can benefit from)

    I would be happy with a 10% discount instead of 25% if that would mean maintaining the quality of the forum… The themes are very good value for money as it is.

     


    Simplicity is not Simple Webtaurus

Viewing 7 posts - 1 through 7 (of 7 total)

You must be logged in to reply to this topic.